Tuesday, April 22, 2008

I get asked "How do I win my election" all the time.  There is no trick to it, figure out the number of people likely to vote in your election and divide by 2 then add 1.  The famous “50% plus 1” rule.  Then get that number of people to vote for you.

Then you need to start and figure out who will vote for you - keeping a tally.  By the way Trail Blazer Campaign Manger helps you keep track of that information.  You didn’t think I would not put in at least one plug, did you?  So the day you start you should have a tally of at least 1 (you).  Hopefully you have a few family and friends that have said they will vote for you.  Build that number up by phone calling and going door to door.  Be sure you have a visual way to keep that tally in front of you everyday of the campaign.  You will want to make sure your tally contains variables for strong support and soft or leaning support. Remember to keep that database, you know - Trail Blazer J, up to date with that information.  Another key don’t guess, ask them.  Many people will say that they like you, be sure to ask “will you vote for me or my opponent”.  In other words if they hedge they are not a strong supporter, mark them as only leaning to you.

If you are not a 3rd party or independent candidate you can skip to the last paragraph.

We work with a lot of 3rd party and independent candidates, the 50% plus 1 doesn’t always apply.  One of the misunderstandings for these candidates is that if it is a three way race they need 33% plus 1.  In some areas and elections this is true; see the Minnesota Governors race of 1998 for example.  But in most cases the districts or wards or other political boundaries have been divided to give one party a “stronghold”.  For example we, Trail Blazer,  worked with a third party campaign in a district that was heavily one party, usually in presidential going as high as 70% and in congressional going on average in the 65% range for the primary party.  The other, I’ll call it the minor party, getting 30-35% of the vote.  You can’t win with 33% plus 1 in that race, the dominate party will get 34-40% because even if the dominant parties candidate is a sleaze ball with all kinds of negative press, most party loyalists will not “break ranks”.  That goes for the minor parties candidate as well.  The reasoning for this is a topic for another day.

So the math on this is a little fuzzy, but in my experience you should think like this if you take 40% of the dominant party’s support (at 65% of total) giving you 26% of total that leaves the dominant party with 39%.  The next trick is doing the same to the minor party.  If you can get the same percent (which is an unlikely feat given you have appealed to the dominant party’s support) from the minor party (at 35% of total) you will have 14% of the total, giving you 40%.  That percent or some reasonable assimilation should be used to get your target voter count.  It is also a pretty nice trick if you can pull it off.  By the way with the dominant party's base level of support at 70% of the vote, and you only getting 40% of the dominant party's and minor partys support it really is not winnable, using math.   

In conclusion to win an election you need to know how many people will vote and how many it will take to win.  Tally and keep track of everyone that will vote for you, keeping in mind that you will need to have a plan for the last days and hours of your election.  In most circles that plan is called the GOTV (Get out the Vote) plan.  So keep those people tallied and marked in your database as supporters will be the key to that plan.

 

Tuesday, April 22, 2008 11:21:50 AM (Central Standard Time, UTC-06:00)
Sunday, July 13, 2008 2:25:55 PM (Central Standard Time, UTC-06:00)
Hi Brian:

I understand your advice and have heard it from just about every tried and true political veteran I've heard from. I'm a first time volunteer campaign manager and don't have any first hand experience. The candidate I'm working with has expressed some skepticism about the technique of asking people if they will vote for us because he thinks they really won't be frank in answering and therefore the info we would be collecting won't be accurate?

What would be your response to this and what should I say to my candidate on the subject?

I'd appreciate any advice you could offer.

Thanks.

Bill Murphy
Bill Murphy
Monday, July 14, 2008 11:29:15 AM (Central Standard Time, UTC-06:00)
Bill - Thanks for the comment.

This line from the entry, kind of covers it:
<blockquote cite"Brian Hanf">
Many people will say that they like you, be sure to ask “will you vote for me or my opponent”. In other words if they hedge they are not a strong supporter, mark them as only leaning to you.</blockquote>

I, like your candidate, also think a lot of people will say they will vote for you but will not. But a lot of people you never talked to (ID) will vote for you, I think the numbers of those will even out the former.

But that being said. What is the alternative? Waiting to find out on election night is not a good plan.

Advice – You have to ask, it is almost as hard as asking for money and lawn sign locations but like those it is needed if you want to win.

Additional advice - going further into the ask. If you ask and they hedge, stumble or just say 'not decided' - let them off the hook, don't ask why or anything else. If they say the other candidate, thank them for being honest (you never want to attack), hope that the other candidate stumbles and you can pick up the vote for being nice.

Bottom line after you try it 20 times you and the candidate will have a good feel for what people say when they are "Strong Support Me", "Leaning Support Me", "undecided", "Strong Support Other", "Leaning Other". You really should try and get the “Strong support Me” to the 50% + 1 number. Be blunt and get an answer or you will not have the data you need.

Depending on your contest you will want 5-10 days before the election to count your “Strong” and see if you have your numbers. Actually you should update the number on a board everyday so you know what you need/have.

NOTE:
You can try live polling or robo-dialers but in a small race you and the candidate really should do it yourself at the door or on the phone. Most Voter ID calls with live operator will cost about $5.00 or more per answered call and about $0.20 for placed calls that did not answer, robo-dialer voter ID is cheaper $0.20 for 1-2 questions answered and $0.05 for placed calls.

Example of GOTV plans:

65-70% strong support ID’s
I would like to say if you have your strong support well over the 50% plus one, that is in the 70% range that you only call 30% of your strong supporters 5 days out and confirm the support and remind of election date and location. The next 30% on 4 days out, next 30% on 3 days out and remainder on day 2. Leaving you with day 1 (Monday before Tuesday) to handle any last minute issues and thank supporters before big day.

So if your vote pool is 10,000. You have 7000 ID’d strong supporters you call 2100 on day 5, 2100 on day 4, 2100 on day 3 and 700 on day 2.

Most likely you will have no where near that ID’d so
20% strong support ID’s and 20% leaning
I would like to say if you have your strong support well over the 50% plus one, that is in the 70% range that you only call 30% of your strong supporters 5 days out and confirm the support and remind of election date and location. The next 30% on 4 days out, next 30% on 3 days out and remainder on day 2. Leaving you with day 1 (Monday before Tuesday) to handle any last minute issues and thank supporters before big day.

So if your vote pool is 10,000. You have Day 8-6 calling ID “undecided” and try and persuade, you can hope this last push will get you 50% of the undecided. So if you have 4000 strong and leaning supporters ID’s that means you can plan on calling at least 2000 undecided people (I suggest households with at least 2 voters in them). That persuasion call is longer and will take 3-4 minutes each, where the GOTV call is 1 minute or shorter. 2000 ID strong supporters you call 1000 on day 5, 1000 on day 4. That leaves day 3 with 1000 leaning supporters and 1000 on day 2. Leaving you with day 1 to call back the 1000 you found on day 8-6 to make sure they get to the poll and vote for you.
All comments require the approval of the site owner before being displayed.
Name
E-mail
Home page

Comment (Some html is allowed: a@href@title, b, blockquote@cite, em, i, strike, strong, sub, sup, u) where the @ means "attribute." For example, you can use <a href="" title=""> or <blockquote cite="Scott">.  

Enter the code shown (prevents robots):

Live Comment Preview